Eamon Flaherty was a celebrity twice in his short life. In June of 1919, he was arrested and charged with killing his family, all of whom (mother, father, three brothers and a baby girl) had been beaten to death with an axe handle on a rainy night in May. The murders were horrific, which meant titillating, which meant money; reporters descended on tiny Crofton, Nebraska like locusts. Eamon Flaherty was held in the Knox County Jail until his trial in October. He granted no interviews, nor did he read the newspaper. After the sentencing hearing in November (NEBRASKA FARMBOY DRAWS DEATH PENALTY FOR GRISLY MURDERS), the locusts flew away, and Eamon Flaherty was moved to the state penitentiary in Lincoln.
Seven years later, his appeals exhausted, 28 year old Eamon Flaherty was executed in Nebraska’s electric chair, and so made the papers again. Reporting the news of Eamon’s death was an excellent way to revisit his crime in grim detail, and the papers reveled in it. There were other stories, too, for the few reporters who did some digging: Eamon never lifted a finger in his own defense– in fact, he barely spoke to his attorneys. Often, he didn’t reply to their letters. They, in turn, went through the apellate process pro forma, with little interest; when Eamon’s thinly worded appeals were exhausted and the switch was thrown, they went on about their lives and never looked back.
Most vexing of all, perhaps, was this: Eamon never offered any explanation. He never tearfully confessed, never offered a motive, never revealed to anyone why he walked through his house that rainy night in May 1919 and methodically murdered his entire family. Rather than an apology, Eamon’s last words were, “Blood for blood. And tell Sully he can have my shoes.”
Michael Sullivan, “Sully”, was my great-uncle, he’s been dead since ‘93. When I was a kid I used to ride my bike to Uncle Sully and Aunt Pat’s house– I remember it was always dim inside, shades drawn. Aunt Pat would always make a fuss, I guess I liked the attention. Years later I found out from my mother that Uncle Sully had done time in prison. She said it was something the family “didn’t talk about” and changed the subject. Verboten. I couldn’t get my mind around old, stoop-shouldered Uncle Sully doing hard time, and he and I had always been close, especially after Aunt Pat died. I decided I would go to the source and ask the man himself. I didn’t know any better, back then.
I drove to Uncle Sully’s house with a six-pack of Miller. I was still just a kid, barely 22 years old– driving over to Sully’s house with some beers seemed like such a novel “just us guys” thing to do. We sat down at the ancient Formica kitchen table and bullshitted for a little while; then I told old Sully I wanted to hear about his time in prison. My great-uncle stared at me for a long time over his beer. The fluorescent lights hummed and the electric clock over the sink hummed back just like when I was a kid. Finally, Sully seemed to reach a decision. He let out a long sigh and said, “If you come back tomorrow, I’ll tell you a story.”
I remember the next day was a Saturday. Sully and I sat at the kitchen table again, and he placed an ancient, worn-fuzzy brown paper grocery bag between us. “Open it,” he said.
I reached inside the bag and removed a pair of old, scuffed, prison-issue shoes: what are sometimes called “chukka boots”. These were ancient– the soles were leather, nailed on. Inside each one– in black ink on a strip of cracked white paint– was the name FLAHERTY in block letters.
“I never told anyone about this,” Sully said, smiling. “But I’m an old man, and I don’t sleep so good any more. Maybe talking is good, I don’t know. Anyway, you wanted to know, so…”
For the next four hours, my great-uncle, Michael Sullivan, talked, and I listened. I don’t think I even got up to pee, although he did, several times, talking all the while through the open bathroom door. My Uncle Sully told me about growing up poor in rural Nebraska, and he told me about robbing a post office and getting away with it, and doing it again and getting caught. And then he told me about his cellmate of five years, Eamon Flaherty.
Eamon Flaherty enlisted in the US Army in January of 1918, a month after the United States declared war. He was sent to France and saw action with the 3rd Infantry Division. During the Second Battle of the Marne, he was thrown through the air and knocked unconscious by a German artillery burst. Although he was physically unhurt, he was “never quite right” after that. Among several items Eamon was relieved of when mustering out of the army were several gold teeth and two human ears. When Eamon returned to Nebraska in 1919, his family, by and large, ignored his strange behavior. They were stoic people– they didn’t ask what had happened to him in France, and he didn’t tell.
Eamon would stand out in the cornfields for hours, whispering. Once he stood there for two days, never moving. He told his sister he was talking with “spirits.” When the family dog turned up dead with it’s throat slit, Eamon said that the “spirits” had told him to do it. “Blood for blood,” he said.
Eamon stopped taking his meals with his family, then stopped sleeping in the house. He slept in the cornfield, or in the hayloft when it rained. He told his family he was “cleansing” himself. And then, one rainy night in May of 1919, Eamon Flaherty walked through the old farmhouse with an axe handle he got from the tool shed, and crushed the skulls of his entire family. Two weeks later, the Knox county sheriff found them. His deputy found Eamon in the cornfield, whispering.
When Uncle Sully got to prison, he was put into Eamon’s cell. Just the two of them, alone. Sully, for the most part, tried to avoid Eamon, tried to make himself small, unthreatening. Gradually, the two men got the feel of each other, like two tomcats sharing the same apartment. After a while, they were comfortable enough to talk to each other. Sully told Eamon about robbing the post office and getting caught, and Eamon told Sully about France, and the trenches, and the German shell. He told Sully about coming home, and hearing spirits in the corn, but he offered no explanation for the murders, and Sully didn’t pry.
Once, Sully and Eamon got into an argument. Sully owed Eamon a pack of cigarettes, but cigarettes didn’t come cheap in the state pen, and Sully was slow in paying back the debt. He dragged it out and made excuses for a few months, until Eamon finally got angry enough to put Sully against the wall and threaten him. Sully gave Eamon his brand new pack right then and there, and went without for a few days, and figured all was forgotten. Eamon never got angry again, and Sully never got in hock to him again, case closed. And eventually, after five years together, Eamon’s appeals ran out, and he was moved to the Death House, and took a ride in the chair.
The next day, a guard arrived at Sully’s cell with a package: Eamon had left Sully his shoes. Inmates got one pair of shoes every five years, but they wore out in about two. To have an extra pair was a luxury indeed. Except…
“Except he did it on purpose, the bastard,” spat Sully. “That wasn’t a gift, it was a curse.”
I told Sully I didn’t understand– which was true, I didn’t. Flaherty’s shoes? These shoes?
“These shoes,” said Sully. “You know the Indian saying about ‘walking a mile in a man’s shoes’? That’s just a poor translation! It’s much more powerful than that; once I touched his shoes…” Sully’s voice trailed off. I could see tears welling up in his old eyes.
“That was Ponca Indian land, all that land up there in Knox County,” Sully said. “We just threw them off of it and took it. Whatever happened to Eamon Flaherty in the war, that knock in the head, it changed him, see? He could see things the rest of us couldn’t. He came home to Crofton, all that anger, rage, from the war…he was wide open, he was, I don’t know…receptive. The Ponca were thrown off their land, and in return they died of malaria, starvation, Sioux raiding parties killed the rest. The Ponca couldn’t come back to live on their land, but they could demand payment, demand sacrifice, and they did. And Eamon was their instrument– the instrument of the curse their shaman laid on the land. And he exacted revenge: blood for blood.
“I didn’t know any of this when he was alive, how could I? All he ever did was ramble, mumble about corn and spirits…but he knew enough to curse me, God Damnit! He never forgave me for the cigarettes…such a small thing, but in prison…and he left me his shoes. And I touched them, put them on. And the curse passed to me.”
Uncle Sully was crying openly now. I reached across the table, tried to comfort him, but he batted my hand away.
“No! You still don’t understand!” he yelled. “Blood for blood! The curse passed to me! I held out for so long, I prayed to God to help me, but…the curse…you kill the ones you love the most, don’t you see? Don’t you see?”
Uncle Sully, grief-stricken, breathed in ragged sobs. “I’m done,” he said. “I should have died years ago, this house is a tomb. After I killed Pat, after I killed my wife for them, I thought I was done, but I was wrong– I had to pass on the curse, I am…was…compelled to live until I pass on the shaman’s curse…but now…”
Of course. I had touched the shoes. My uncle had laid the curse on me, and now, at last could die– did die. Old uncle Sully died four months later, in his bed, the bastard. And me? I have three children, a beautiful wife…and I’m so tired.
Blood for blood.